Michele Carmo, Giulio Mercandalli, Alberto M. Settembrini, Patrizia Lattuada, George Prouse, Andrea Rignano, Pietro Bassi, Piergiorgio G. Settembrini
S.Carlo Borromeo Hospital-Milan, Milan, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Late results from NASCET and ECST showed a greater benefit for surgery if performed within 4 weeks from symptoms. Recent studies have emphasized the risk of stroke after TIAs and of stroke recurrence after a first episode. Our aim is to describe our experience in treating symptomatic carotid stenosis in an emergency setting.
METHODS: All patients admitted for acute neurologic deficits to the Stroke Unit from 1/2002 to 9/2008 were considered possible candidates to surgery. Those treated within 36 hrs from positive carotid imaging studies were reviewed. All patients received a brain CT and an ABCD2 or NIHSS score, as appropriate. Surgery was not offered if NIHSS>22. TIA was defined by deficits lasting <24 hrs and negative CT for 72 hrs. Stroke was defined by symptoms lasting >24 hrs or positive CT. Neurologic complications were defined by a worsening NIHSS or new area of brain ischemia at CT. End points were perioperative death / neurological morbidity as per NIHSS.
RESULTS: Among 55 patients (40 male, mean age 69±9.8 yrs), 17 were admitted for TIA (3 amaurosis, 8 single TIA, 6 recurrent) with a mean ABCD2 score of 3.2±1.6 at admission; 38 had a stroke (34 minor, 4 stroke in evolution), with a median NIHSS of 3 (IQR 2-7.5); 14 of them had a positive CT. Median time from symptoms to observation was 4 hrs (2-7), from observation to surgery 34 hrs (9-115), with no difference between TIAs and strokes. We performed 54 endarterectomies (37 patch, 14 direct, 3 eversion) and 1 embolectomy. Local or regional anesthesia was used in 20 patients and general in 35. Among TIAs 1 patient died of an MI and 2 patients suffered a TIA postoperatively. In the stroke group 1 patient died of a cerebral hemorrhage arisen on fourth postop day, being symptoms free until then. 2 patients had a TIA (1 arm weakness and 1 amaurosis). 3 patients experienced a worsening NIHSS: 2 had a stroke while the third had a hyperperfusion syndrome (all CTs negative during hospital stay). Median NIHSS at discharge was 2 (1-3). Overall the death/stroke rate was 5.9% for TIA patients and 10.5% for stroke.
CONCLUSIONS: Early surgery had higher perioperative mortality and stroke rates than expected. This can probably be acceptable for TIAs if compared to their risk of stroke. Stroke patients most likely need a better selection in order to pick up those who can benefit from early treatment.
AUTHOR DISCLOSURES: M. Carmo, None; G. Mercandalli, None; A.M. Settembrini, None; P. Lattuada, None; G. Prouse, None; A. Rignano, None; P. Bassi, None; P.G. Settembrini, None.